How many bikes you need in an office may sound like a trivial matter, but for developers, it is an issue that can cost hundreds of thousands of pounds in what many deem to be an unnecessary cost.
Waste of space: according to the LPA, 84% of mandated cycle spaces in buildings designed to standards outlined by the current London Plan go unused
A report published last week by the London Property Alliance (LPA) reveals that 76% of existing cycle parking spaces were vacant at peak periods, and if all the buildings covered in its study had been designed to standards outlined by the current London Plan, adopted in 2021, up to 84% of mandated cycle spaces would remain empty.
The report coincided with a Times podcast in which Taylor Wimpey chief executive Jennie Daly said the housebuilder had quit London due to “fundamentally broken” viability.
These two viewpoints highlight one common problem: that building in London has become simply too tough.
With the consultation on a new draft London Plan closing this week, the question for policymakers in London is whether a number of rules and regulations have tipped the viability balance firmly out of developers’ favour, and how this issue can be resolved.
Regulatory purgatory
The regulatory burdens have been adding up, with one source complaining to Property Week about the “excessive” number of kitchens required in co-living schemes – “as if planners think everybody lives like they do in the TV show Friends”. The feeling among many in the industry is that development faces a death by 1,000 regulatory cuts.
“There are so many additional standards in the London Plan that go beyond the regulatory requirements of Section 106, CIL [the Community Infrastructure Levy], the Building Safety Levy or building regulations, which themselves have become much more stringent,” says Lindsay Garratt, partner at law firm Winckworth Sherwood.
She acknowledges that Jules Pipe, deputy mayor of London for planning, regeneration and the fire service, has tried to reassure the industry that the draft plan doesn’t create any more burdens on developers.
However, she adds: “There is a disconnect in terms of how they [the Greater London Authority] think the plan is drafted and how developers think it’s drafted.”
Councils need to recognise developers are partners rather than adversaries
Amardip Healy, Blake Morgan
Victoria Du Croz, partner and head of planning at law firm Forsters, points out that the London Plan is designed to be a strategic, rather than prescriptive, document. However, it is the detailed guidance that sits behind the plan that can cause issues.
“If you apply the planning formula rigidly, then half your public realm is taken up with bike racks,” she says. “It’s a classic planning issue about applying balance – and when that gets distorted to fit a formula, you end up with ridiculous approaches. People [such as councillors or planning officers] get hung up on that and give greater weight to it than more nebulous ideas.”
This view is echoed by Amardip Healy, legal director at law firm Blake Morgan, who says we need a culture shift as much as we need a policy one. “Councils need to take a more pragmatic, delivery-focused approach to development and recognise that developers are partners who will help them tackle the housing crisis, rather than adversaries,” she says.
The draft London Plan will be scrutinised during the Examination in Public (EIP) process next year, and many will hope that those in charge will listen to the myriad concerns.
Garratt hopes London’s many planning ambiguities will be resolved during the EIP, ahead of adoption of the plan in 2028. The Greater London Authority did introduce emergency measures, including temporary relief from the CIL, to help solve viability issues facing housebuilders in March this year; however, those are temporary and don’t go far enough, she says.
“It’s a time-limited relief that’s getting smaller every day, and yet we still don’t have the updated regs,” Garratt adds. “There is a lot of frustration that, as a measure to help kickstart housebuilding, it is taking far too long”.
Mind the gap
Jamie Sullivan, planning partner at advisory firm Bidwells, says that the London Plan and its restrictions reflect the kind of city the mayor and the Greater London Authority are trying to create.
With this in mind, the focus on density is also a key issue, with targets of 90 dwellings per hectare (DPH) on green-belt land as a minimum, up to 160 DPH if less than 400m from a railway station.
“Those density requirements mean you’re not delivering family homes; a flat is the best you can hope for, and a three-bed flat is not attractive to families,” Sullivan says.
He adds that only around 5% of the million or so homes in London built over the past 20 years were family homes, leaving a substantial unmet need.
But Sullivan does acknowledge that policymakers face multiple pressures: “It’s very hard for central government to turn around and say they are going to roll back sustainability standards, and it’s starting to cause a headache in terms of viability.”
He points out that the current London Plan’s approach to housing on green-belt land is far more restrictive than that of the planning authorities that surround the capital.
Our clients won’t go near London, and the reason is viability
Victoria Du Croz, Forsters
He outlines the difference in approach when it comes to residential schemes. “If you went a mile or so north into the home counties, they would be biting your arm off for these homes, because they would be incredibly sustainable [for their own local plans], but also because if they are across the boundary into London, all of sudden they are assessed on totally different criteria,” Sullivan says, highlighting air quality requirements and congestion issues.
The findings of the LPA’s report are echoed in another report released this week led by former housing minister Lord Barwell, which calls for the use of Section 106 to be restricted to what individual developments need.
The Prosper UK Housing Commission report outlines how a 300-home build-to-rent scheme that would have made £8m in profit in 2020 would now make a £6m loss. The report calls for new regulatory burdens to be frozen for at least three years.
Charles Ferguson-Davie, chief executive and chief investment officer at Moorfield Group, which has a portfolio spanning both commercial and residential properties, argues that, ultimately, a review of how to reduce costs across development is needed, along with an understanding from policymakers over what helps and what hinders investment decisions for schemes.
“Lots of incremental, seemingly innocuous and often well-intentioned policies and regulations that make sense have contributed over many years to making the bill too high in aggregate and have also affected demand,” he says. “For me, the absolute killer is the late-stage review process; it just doesn’t work.”
London’s loss?
The impact is being very much felt on the ground. “If you speak to any of our investor clients at the moment on residential, they won’t go near London, and the reason is viability,” says Forsters’ Du Croz.
Ferguson-Davie says his company has chosen to look outside London for many of its schemes, mainly due to the cost of building in the capital.
“We’ve done three very successful multi-family schemes in Manchester and none in London, and so there must be a reason for that,” he says. He adds: “We do have a current co-living scheme in Ealing. It’s our only build-to-rent scheme in the city; but we’d like to do a lot more.
“We’ve just found it very difficult to find the schemes that stack up, certainly when you compare the opportunity to what we could be doing in other places.”